When we say or GPS tracker(Global Positioning System), the very first brand our brain remembers is none other than Garmin. It is using GPS in the automobile industry since the late 80’s. On the other hand, there is another company that is comparatively new but has been solely into the manufacturing of health tracker devices. Any guesses? Well, yes it is Fitbit. Now if an activity tracker comes with a GPS system, it would be a boon.

It would be a tedious task to choose between Garmin’s Vivoactive and Fitbit’s Surge as both of them are doing a splendid job in the current market. However, it will appear to be a lot simpler as we go ahead with Fitbit Surge vs. Garmin Vivoactive comparison to know which gadget serves you better for your requirement.

Fitbit Surge vs Garmin Vivoactive

Design & Hardware

The Surge is a kind of a wristband that comes in 3 different sober colors & sizes. The wristband is made of flexible elastometer, which is very durable and the clasp is made of surgical grade stainless steel. On the other hand, Vivoactive is a kind of smartwatch that comes in only two basic colors, i.e., white & black. However, you can change the bands for several color options. The Vivoactive is not much attractive, and the design is not at par with the inbuilt features. The material used in Vivoactive is same as Surge. While the later has a monochrome LCD backlight and touch screen display, the former has a colored touch screen display with a high resolution that can be read during broad daylight.

Activity Tracking

The Surge is a multi-function device; everything can be tracked and monitored — biking, running, cardio workouts, etc. It tracks the distance more accurately with the help of GPS than the Vivoactive. You can get a complete statistics of your route, elevation, speed, etc. with precision. The add-on in Surge is the continuous heart rate monitoring, which keeps track of all the data in a detailed record. This feature gives surge an edge over Vivoactive.


The Vivoactive device can be connected to a heart rate monitor through a chest strap whereas, in Surge, you do not need such an add-on to perform the task. Vivoactive allows you to track your activity while swimming. Surge does not have such feature. It is only water resistance but not a swim proof device. The usage of the apps in Surge enables you to see your daily activities, sleep, record sessions, the workout history, etc. You can even compete with your friends by using Surge. Your friends can automatically connect with you and can see your daily goals, food intake and other activity related details. With this app in Surge, you can compete with your friends’ daily activity and earn badges. Other than Android and iOS platforms, Surge supports windows mobile as well, so you need not worry about the OS your mobile device runs on.

Most app functions are common in both Vivoactive & Surge. However, the syncing is very quick and certainly better (number of attempts in getting connected) in Vivoactive.


You can use your smartwatch for checking notifications like incoming calls, text messages & can even control music by a touch in both. The difference between Vivoactive & Surge is that Vivo notifies you about WhatsApp, Facebook, cab arrivals, etc., unlike Surge, which lacks in such features. So if you are a social media freak & want all the notifications on the go, then Vivoactive is surely a better option.


Fitbit Surge vs. Garmin Vivoactive comparison helps you know the advantages and shortcomings of both the devices. Primarily the basic features like tracking of activity, calorie intake, calories burnt, distance covered steps, goal setting, sleep quality, sleep time, GPS tracking, etc. features are common in both. However, Surge gives you an extra add-on: it tracks your heart rate without connecting it to an external device. The elevation you have climbed is also recorded which is absent in Vivoactive.

Check out more comparison: Smartwatches & Fitness Trackers Comparison

The battery standby duration for the surge is up to 7 days however in Vivoactive it can be up to 3 weeks in watch mode & up to 10 hrs in GPS mode. The GPS standby duration is less in Vivoactive than Surge. Surge uses lithium polymer battery whereas Vivoactive uses a lithium ion battery.

Other features include a digital clock, silent alarm, online patrol that is enabled via GPS, music settings controlling and such can be done while on the go – these features are common on both devices.

The features that differentiate them are as follows:

  • The surge has a Barcode scanner and Vivoactive does not.
  • The former has a heart rate monitor inbuilt but, the later does not have such feature.
  • The syncing process is almost the same for both, but the differentiating factor is the OS compatibility of these devices.
  • Surge supports all the OS including windows but, Vivo does not support windows phone.
  • Vivoactive is compatible with all the versions of Mac OS whereas surge supports only Mac OS*10.6 and above.

Comparison with other products:

If we compare the pioneer of innovation, i.e., Apple, they have a product named Apple watch, which is highly integrated and technically more advanced than both Vivoactive & Fitbit Surge. Also, Android wear brigade and other players including HTC have launched their products with similar specifications, some being more advanced. Fitbit Surge & Garmin Vivoactive has most of the prominent features, and both are cost effective when compared to other advanced gadgets.


In price wise, Garmin Vivoactive got the edge over Fitbit Surge. Fitbit Surge is priced at $215.84 , and Garmin Vivoactive is priced at $181.75


Both the gadgets come with one year warranty. Still it is recommended to visit their website’s warranty page to know more about Garmin & Fitbit’s Consumer warranty details.

Which One Should You Buy?

Accuracy plays the major part in all health devices. In regards to fitness trackers, both price and accuracy does matter a lot. Fitbit and Garmin has the brand loyalty with their customers from the start. But checking out all the features comparison of the devices, Garmin wins the race with their notification support, GPS track, and heart rate tracking feature. It also act as a smartwatch, so you will be getting smartwatch with fitness tracker features.

Also read this: Garmin Vivofit vs Fitbit Charge HR